AMERICAN WHISKEY (the store's "American / Craft" section)
American whiskey is the whole family of whiskeys made in the United States — and this is the gateway to all of it in the vault. It spans the two great Kentucky styles, bourbon and rye, plus Tennessee whiskey, corn and wheat whiskeys, and the newest category, American single malt, recognized by federal regulators in 2025. Behind them sit the legacy houses — Buffalo Trace, Heaven Hill, Wild Turkey — and a new generation of craft distillers. Use this page to choose a style or house, then follow the link to its collection.
- Bourbon — at least 51% corn, aged in new charred oak.
- Rye — at least 51% rye, under the same oak rule.
- Tennessee whiskey — bourbon made in Tennessee and filtered through maple charcoal (the Lincoln County Process).
- Corn, wheat & malt whiskeys — built on at least 80% corn, or at least 51% wheat or malted barley.
- American single malt — 100% malted barley, distilled at a single U.S. distillery; a TTB standard effective January 2025.
- Across the board: distilled to no more than 160 proof, bottled at no less than 80; "straight" means at least two years in oak.
American whiskey is really a family. Bourbon and rye are the Kentucky heavyweights — corn-led and sweet, or rye-led and spicy. Tennessee whiskey starts as bourbon, then mellows through maple charcoal. Corn whiskey leans almost entirely on corn and needn't see new charred oak; wheat and malt whiskeys foreground those grains. The newest member, American single malt, is 100% malted barley from a single distillery — America's answer to Scotch. New charred oak ties much of it together, supplying the vanilla, caramel and color.
For most of the 20th century, American whiskey meant a handful of large Kentucky and Tennessee distilleries. That changed in the 2000s: a wave of small, independent "craft" distillers opened across the country, reviving lost styles like Monongahela rye and pioneering new ones. Their push is a big reason American single malt earned its own federal standard in 2025. Today the category runs from century-old houses to distilleries only a few years old — and the vault carries both.
Styles & Distilleries at a Glance
Browse the vault's American whiskey by style, distillery or release:
| By Style | |
| Bourbon | The corn-led American classic — sweet and full-bodied. |
| Rye | The rye-led style — spicier and drier; America's original whiskey. |
| Distilleries | |
| Buffalo Trace Distillery | Frankfort, Kentucky — the source of much of the vault's bourbon and rye. |
| Heaven Hill Distillery | The largest family-owned American distillery. |
| Wild Turkey | The Russell family's high-proof Kentucky whiskey. |
| Single Brands | |
| Blanton's | The original single-barrel bourbon. |
| W.L. Weller | The wheated bourbon family. |
| Pappy Van Winkle | The wheated, ultra-aged vertical. |
| Stagg & George T. Stagg | Buffalo Trace's barrel-proof bourbon. |
| Allocated, Vintage & Picks | |
| Buffalo Trace Antique Collection | The annual allocated release of the distillery's oldest stock. |
| Dusty Bottles | Vintage Americana from closed or changed distilleries. |
| Barrel Picks | Single-barrel selections chosen for Midnight Whiskey. |
| Best Sellers | The most-wanted bottles right now. |
Tennessee whiskey, corn and wheat whiskeys, and American single malt appear within Best Sellers and Barrel Picks as they're stocked — ask the concierge for current craft and specialty bottles.
Collector Note
American whiskey's most sought-after tier is Kentucky — the Buffalo Trace Antique Collection, wheated Weller and Pappy Van Winkle, and single-barrel and barrel-proof releases that trade well above retail. But the field is widening: bonded bottles, vintage "dusty" Americana, and a young American single malt scene are all drawing collectors. Whatever the style, the specific release, proof and condition decide value.
The American Whiskey Types
American whiskey is a family of types defined by the U.S. federal Standards of Identity (27 CFR part 5). Bourbon must be at least 51% corn and aged in new charred oak; rye at least 51% rye under the same oak rule; wheat and malt whiskeys at least 51% wheat or malted barley; corn whiskey at least 80% corn (and, unusually, needn't use new charred oak). Tennessee whiskey is bourbon made in Tennessee and filtered through sugar-maple charcoal — the Lincoln County Process. American single malt, recognized in a TTB rule effective January 19, 2025, must be 100% malted barley, distilled entirely at one U.S. distillery to no more than 160 proof, and matured in oak barrels of up to 700 liters (new or used). Most American whiskeys are distilled to no more than 160 proof and bottled at no less than 80; "straight" means at least two years in oak, and "bottled-in-bond" means one distillery and one season, four years, 100 proof.
Authentication & Vault Preservation
Every American whiskey sold through Midnight Whiskey is sourced as an authorized, authentic retailer, vault-stored and insured, shipped with protective handling and age-verified 21-and-over signature on delivery, and authenticated by our concierge before it ships. For more, see the authentication behind every bottle, vault storage and the concierge, and how we source what we sell.
Frequently Asked Questions
What counts as American whiskey?
American whiskey is whiskey made in the United States, with several federally defined types. Bourbon is at least 51% corn; rye at least 51% rye; wheat and malt whiskeys at least 51% of those grains; corn whiskey at least 80% corn. American single malt — recognized by the TTB in a rule effective January 2025 — is 100% malted barley distilled at a single U.S. distillery. Tennessee whiskey is essentially bourbon filtered through maple charcoal and made in Tennessee. Most are distilled to no more than 160 proof and bottled at no less than 80.
What's the difference between bourbon, rye and American single malt?
It comes down to grain and oak. Bourbon is at least 51% corn and must use new charred oak; rye is at least 51% rye under the same oak rule; American single malt is 100% malted barley and may use new or used oak of up to 700 liters. Bourbon tends to be sweet, rye spicier and drier, and single malt more malt-forward — closer in spirit to Scotch but made entirely in the U.S. All three are American whiskey.
115 products
